Is It Cheaper to Buy Bags of Concrete or Get a Truck?

Bags are cheaper only for small jobs. Under about one cubic yard buying bags wins, and over about two cubic yards a delivered ready-mix truck is cheaper on both the concrete and your back; the one-to-two-yard range in between is genuinely close and worth pricing both ways. Whether it is cheaper to buy bags or get a truck is not decided by the price per yard, where the truck almost always wins, but by the flat delivery and short-load fees a small order carries and the hours of mixing bags by hand. Here is the cost at each size and the point where it flips.

What each option costs by volume

Bagged concrete is counted in 80 lb bags, each yielding 0.60 cubic feet, so a cubic yard takes 45 of them. Ready-mix is sold by the cubic yard, delivered, at around $160 a yard, the average selling price the industry reports in its own benchmarking survey. Line them up:

Bagged concrete against delivered ready-mix, by volume, material only
Volume80 lb bagsBag cost at $6.25Ready-mix delivered
0.5 yd³23$144$80 plus fees
1 yd³45$281$160 plus fees
2 yd³90$563$320 plus fees
3 yd³135$844$480 plus fees
5 yd³225$1,406$800

The bag counts are the net volume divided by 0.60 cubic feet and rounded up, with no waste added; add the usual 10 percent and each count climbs. The bag cost uses $6.25 for an 80 lb bag, the current store-pickup median at the big-box chains. The ready-mix column is the concrete and delivery at $160 a yard, before the short-load fee covered below.

Why bags lose on the concrete itself

Pound for pound, bagged concrete is the expensive way to buy the same material. At $6.25 an 80 lb bag, a cubic yard of bags is $281 of material before you have opened one, against $160 for the same yard delivered. That gap is real and it widens with every yard: at 5 cubic yards it is $1,406 of bags against roughly $800 of ready-mix. You are paying for the bag, the packaging and the convenience of buying it off a shelf, and none of that scales in your favor.

So on the concrete alone, the truck wins at every size from half a yard up. The only thing that pulls the decision back toward bags is what the truck adds around the edges.

What the truck adds, and when bags still win

Two costs sit on top of the per-yard price and hit small orders hardest:

  • The short-load fee. Order less than a full load and the supplier adds a fee for the trouble of a part-filled truck. Published supplier schedules set the threshold at three to seven yards and the fee at a flat $100 to $300, not a per-yard charge, so it lands as one lump on a small pour. Ready-mix delivery has the real fee schedules.
  • Delivery and a minimum. The truck has to drive to you whether you take half a yard or ten, and many suppliers will not come out for a tiny order at all. Below about half a yard there is often no truck to price, which is the real reason bags win at the bottom end.

Put the fee back in and the small sizes tighten up. A half-yard delivered is about $80 of concrete plus a flat $100 to $300, so $180 to $380 against $144 of bags: here the bags are the cheaper buy, and a supplier may not come out for so little anyway. A single yard is $160 plus the fee, $260 to $460 against $281 of bags, which straddles the bag price and is why that band is genuinely close. By two yards the truck is $320 plus the fee, $420 to $620 against $563 of bags, so the truck is usually ahead though still close at the top of the fee range; past two yards it pulls away for good.

Then there is the labor nobody prices. Forty-five bags to the yard is most of a day for two people with a rented mixer, and 3,600 lb lifted twice, once into the mixer and once into the forms. Bags also win regardless of the arithmetic when access decides it: a back garden the truck cannot reach, or a pour you would rather do in stages. How to mix concrete covers doing it by hand once you have decided.

Where it flips, in one line

Under a yard, buy bags: the truck's fees and minimum outweigh the cheaper concrete, and a supplier may not deliver so little anyway. From one to two yards, price it both ways, because the short-load fee and your own time decide it. Over about two yards, order the truck: it is cheaper on material and it saves you a day of mixing. For the bag counts at any size, measure the pour and let the concrete bag calculator return the count in each bag size; to price a delivered load against bags for your own volume, use the concrete cost calculator. The bags per yard guide has the full count table, and cost per yard of concrete breaks down the delivered price.

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to buy bags or get a concrete truck?

Only for small jobs. Under about a cubic yard, bags win because the truck's delivery and short-load fees outweigh its cheaper concrete, and many suppliers will not deliver so little. Above about two cubic yards a delivered truck is cheaper on both the material and the labor. The one-to-two-yard band is close, so price it both ways.

How many 80 lb bags equal a truck load?

45 bags of 80 lb mix make one cubic yard, since each yields 0.60 cubic feet. A small 3-yard delivery is 135 bags, and a 5-yard load is 225. That is 3,600 lb of bags per yard to carry and mix by hand, which is most of why the truck wins once you pass a yard or two.

At what size should I switch from bags to ready-mix?

Around one to two yards. The crossover is set by the flat short-load fee and the hours of mixing, not by the price per yard, where the truck is cheaper at every size from half a yard up. Below a yard, bags; above two yards, the truck.

Why is a small ready-mix order so expensive per yard?

The fixed costs of sending a truck do not shrink with your order. Published supplier schedules add a short-load fee, a flat $100 to $300, on loads under a three to seven yard threshold, and that lump is spread over just a yard or two. Delivery and a possible minimum sit on top.